[Spoiler alert: The Bachelor Season 24.] We should have seen it coming, Bachelor Nation fans. Throughout Peter Weber’s season, the fandom has criticized the 28-year-old bachelor for his indecisive behavior. Then in the two-night finale on March 9 and 10, Pilot Pete proposed to Hannah Ann Sluss after Madison Prewett self-eliminated. However, in a turn of events, Weber broke off the engagement with Hannah Ann and ended up with Madison. But if the tables were turned, would Hannah Ann get back together with Weber? The model recently shared what she would have done if she were in Madison’s shoes.
Peter Weber chose Madison Prewett after getting engaged to Hannah Ann Sluss on ‘The Bachelor’
As mentioned, Weber has been called out for his inability to make decisions during The Bachelor Season 24. Then in February 2020, the Delta pilot addressed the criticisms after his reunion with The Bachelorette‘s Hannah Brown and everything that happened with Alayah Benavidez resulted in some backlash.
When speaking with Access, Weber told fans they had “nothing to worry about” when it came to him “being indecisive about certain decisions.” However, those comments didn’t exactly hold up. And by The Bachelor finale, everyone witnessed Weber’s struggles rise again as he chose between his final two.
After getting engaged and breaking things off with Hannah Ann, it seemed Weber and Madison would get back together — or at least work towards it. On The Bachelor‘s live taping of After the Final Rose, Weber and Madison revealed they were in love and wanted to mend their relationship, taking things one day at a time.
But if things were different, would Hannah Ann have done the same? In an interview with Rachel Lindsay and Becca Kufrin on the Bachelor Happy Hour podcast, Hannah Ann revealed she would have run in the opposite direction.
“If you look back on this season, you see Peter’s pattern of behavior of being consistently indecisive and confused, then I’d be running for the hills,” Hannah Ann said. “Even if he’s saying he loves you, look at his pattern of behavior. The one consistency he has ever had is being confused, conflicted, and torn.”
“His consistency is inconsistency,” Lindsay added. Then the 23-year-old agreed. “If you want to ride that emotional roller coaster with him, go for it,” Hannah Ann said. “I just got off of it. And it’s a wild ride.”
Madison Prewett and Peter Weber broke up after ‘The Bachelor’
Of course, it’s possible Madison did what Hannah Ann would have done in the end. Two days after sharing they would try to move forward on The Bachelor finale, Madison and Weber announced their split in two separate statements.
“Madi and I have mutually decided to not pursue our relationship any further,” Weber wrote on Instagram. “Believe me this was not easy for either of us to be ok with, but after a lot of honest conversations, we have agreed that this is what makes most sense for the two of us.”
Meanwhile, Madison wrote: “As Peter and I have decided to go our separate ways, I am confident that we will both move in the direction of our purpose and never forget that God has a plan in all things. I will always love and respect him. I am convinced our paths were meant to cross and we are both better because they did.”
Does Hannah Ann Sluss think Peter Weber would want to get back together after breaking up with Madison Prewett?
Given Weber’s wishy-washy history with letting go of his exes, would the bachelor consider getting back together with Hannah Ann? Still speaking with Lindsay and Kufrin on Bachelor Happy Hour — which was recorded days before the breakup announcement — Hannah Ann admitted she wouldn’t be surprised if Weber wanted to come back to her in the case things didn’t work out with Madison.
“Honestly you guys, I don’t put anything past Peter Weber. I don’t!” Hannah Ann said. “He’s just so all over the place. He’s so lost.”
But considering Hannah Ann’s remarks about “running for the hills,” it’s highly unlikely the model would actually get back together with Weber. So with that, it’s time to move on. Goodbye, The Bachelor Season 24. You will not be missed.